In a fast-paced fashion world, consignment stores have become a go-to for those looking to score fabulous deals while supporting sustainable practices. But with so many options, how do you know which platform is the real deal?
Yes, Poshmark is legit but with a number of unreliable sellers. We’re exploring the world of consignment in Canada, comparing popular platforms like Poshmark and Depop, and exploring why The Peacock Boutique Consignment might be your new favourite destination for shopping second-hand fashion.
What Is Consignment?
At its core, consignment is a method where you can sell your gently used items through a third-party platform or store. As a seller, you don’t have to worry about the hassle of setting up your shop or dealing with the logistics of selling directly to buyers. Instead, consignment platforms take care of that for you.
On the consumer side, consignment has grown in popularity as it combines convenience with eco-friendliness. Shoppers can browse various items while contributing to sustainable consumption. It’s a win-win for fashion enthusiasts who care about style and the planet.
For Canadian consumers, consignment offers access to a broader range of items than what might be available at other retail locations, often including unique finds and rare pieces. But with more options come more questions—specifically, which platform offers the best experience?
What Are the Options for Consignment in Canada?
Canada has countless consignment shops, many of them traditional brick-and-mortar, like Plato’s Closet. Plato’s Closet offers options of gently used items, from trendy to timeless. Rummaging around for treasures and rare finds is certainly part of the fun of secondhand clothing.
Online-only consignment shops, like Poshmark or Depop, are known for their extensive user bases and diverse offerings. They can connect buyers directly with sellers, creating an experience akin to digging through a digital thrift store. However, their model also means variability in quality and shipping costs. And what if you want to know the people you’re selling from?
Enter The Peacock Boutique Consignment, an option that is perfect for those looking for desirable, gently-used clothing. Focusing on quality, like-new items, The Peacock Boutique Consignment offers 3 beautiful locations in Calgary to shop from. You can dig around for something just right from whichever location works for you, with the additional security that comes with buying from a centralized, family-owned business. But more on that later!

What Is Depop & How Does It Work?
Depop is an app-based platform that allows users to buy and sell second-hand clothing, accessories, and even art.
Sellers list their items, complete with descriptions and photos, and buyers browse through the various “shops.” Once an item catches your eye, you can purchase it directly from the seller.
The downside? Each transaction comes with its own shipping cost, and quality control is largely in the hands of individual sellers. If you buy multiple items in the same afternoon, you may have to pay for shipping on each individual item you purchase per seller. There is a lack of centralized quality control, and there is no guarantee that the item you are buying comes as described.
The bottom line: Depop’s setup means buyers must exercise caution and rely on seller reviews for a satisfactory purchase, every time.
What Is Poshmark & How Does It Work?
Poshmark operates similarly to Depop but targets a broader demographic, including both high-fashion aficionados and casual thrifters.
To start shopping, users create an account, follow their favourite sellers, and explore listings that suit their tastes. Each purchase involves direct communication with the seller, allowing for negotiation and inquiries about the item.
While Poshmark’s user-driven model offers variety, like Depop, it also means variability in quality control. Buyers must be vigilant about checking seller ratings and product descriptions. Additionally, Poshmark requires separate shipping payments for each transaction, which can add up quickly.
What Is Plato’s Closet & How Does It Work?
Plato’s Closet offers a slightly different take on the consignment model, focusing on gently used teen and young adult clothing. With over 400 locations across North America, Plato’s Closet provides a more traditional in-person consignment experience.
Customers bring their items to a local store, where staff evaluate them based on style, condition, and demand. Sellers receive cash on the spot for accepted items, making it an attractive option for those looking for a quick turnaround.
Plato’s Closet typically houses a large amount of inventory, which can be great from a selection standpoint, but means that their quality standards will be more broad, and some shoppers find the experience overwhelming. Also, their high-volume consignment model may not give you the best sale price as a consignor. While it can offer great finds for local shoppers, it may not satisfy those seeking more premium, quality finds.
What Makes The Peacock Boutique Consignment Unique?
The Peacock Boutique Consignment, a Canadian business through-and through, based in Calgary, offers a refreshing alternative to other platforms by combining the sustainability of shopping local with the assurance of quality control. With a carefully curated selection of items, The Peacock Boutique Consignment ensures that everything they offer meets high standards for condition and style.
Unlike other platforms that rely on individual sellers, The Peacock Boutique Consignment operates as a centralized entity, meaning all purchases come from a single source.
For those who appreciate a more refined shopping experience, The Peacock Boutique Consignment aims to provide a sense of confidence. You can trust that each piece has been evaluated for quality, ensuring your purchase feels like a brand-new treasure.
Reliability & Quality Control
Reliability and quality control are critical concerns when shopping for second-hand items. While platforms like Depop and Poshmark offer vast selections, buyers must rely on sellers’ honesty and accuracy in descriptions. This can lead to mixed experiences, with some items arriving in less-than-expected conditions.
The Peacock Boutique Consignment sets itself apart by emphasizing quality control. Each item is meticulously inspected and vetted before being listed, ensuring that customers receive pieces in like-new condition. Our commitment to quality means buyers can shop confidently, knowing their expectations will be met.
Additionally, because we operate as a single entity, the level of accountability and transparency is significantly higher. Customers can trust that they will receive products that align with their values and standards.
Supporting Local, Conveniently
By choosing The Peacock Boutique Consignment, shoppers invest in a local, family-owned business prioritizing sustainability and community.
Our commitment to offering high-quality, pre-loved items aligns with consumers’ values about reducing their environmental impact. Shopping locally also means supporting a business that understands and caters to Calgarians’ and Canadians’ unique tastes and preferences.
Shop with The Peacock Boutique Consignment
Canadian consumers have no shortage of options in the dynamic world of consignment. Platforms like Depop and Poshmark can offer extensive selections, while Plato’s Closet can provide a more traditional shopping experience.
The Peacock Boutique Consignment stands out as a leader in quality and convenience. Offering great finds, stringent quality control, and a commitment to supporting local, it appeals to fashion enthusiasts who value both style and sustainability.
Ready to elevate your wardrobe while supporting a local business? Visit The Peacock Boutique Consignment today and discover the joy of sustainably, conveniently, and stylishly shopping, in person at one of our 3 Calgary locations.